Akathist hymn “Glory to God for all things”—a critique

This Akathist hymn is taking the western Orthodox world by storm. This is puzzling to me. Recently I listened to it for the first time and it struck me how non-traditional it is. It speaks a language and betrays an ethos which do not belong to our Tradition. In a few words, this is the ethos that does not want to die.

And for our Tradition, as Scripture says, to live in Christ is to lose one’s life, to experience the death of Christ in one’s body. The only way to live is to die.

In sharp contrast, this akathist does not want to die. It has no sense of asceticism, which defines our Tradition. Rather it is a long poem of modern emotionalism, inflated with an askew sense of the cosmos and of life. It speaks of the darkness of the latter as a contrast to Christ, rather than the presence of the death of Christ in the world. It speaks of the cosmos as nature, rather than creation. And it is in awe of nature in the most sentimentalist Franciscan sense (and Franciscan spirituality has produced things much better than the sentimentalism to which it is commonly associated).

The expectation of the life in Christ as the good life is particularly disturbing. When one says things such as “The dark storm clouds of life bring no terror to those in whose hearts Thy fire is burning brightly,” one has forgotten Scripture, especially St. Paul’s description of the life in Christ as the death of the self (2 Cor 4-6).

It saddens me how quickly this takes over my world.

Let me go to hell! My love is insatiable

St. John Chrysostom in his Second Homily to Eutropios says the following:

I am insatiable, I do not wish many to be saved but all. And if but one be left in a perishing condition, I perish also, and deem that the Shepherd should be imitated who had ninety-nine sheep, and yet hastened after the one which had gone astray (Luke 15:4).

He is basically saying: for the sake of any one person I will abandon heaven and go to hell with him/her. This is the meaning he finds in the parable of the shepherd who abandons ninety-nine sheep to go after the one who has gone astray. In this perfectly loving state the saint resembles so many other saints of our Orthodox tradition.

Learning from the Fathers: Geronda Aimilianos of Simonopetra

To commune truly with the humble God, we must be humble. . . In the person of Christ we can see that humility is a quality of God, a feature of His hypostasis. God is not God if He is not humble. And neither can I be like god unless I am humble. Indeed, without humility, I’ll become a demon.

The ultimate theological method

Of course there have always been places and times to talk and to write. Yet, today we live in a culture in which, if one has something to say, one feels compelled to say it, and to say it loud, all over the internet or in books meant to impress. Regardless of how theological these expressed thoughts are, it is very easy then to lose track of the fact that the ultimate theological method is silence. And this reality is precisely the reason for which all the written books of the Fathers are not worth two minutes of the quiet heart of the Theotokos.